Opinion: Very real fears about a Trump presidency

Print More

By Eric Luedtke

For MarylandReporter.com

Trump by DonkeyHotey with Flickr Creative Commons License

Trump by DonkeyHotey with Flickr Creative Commons License

The day after the election, a constituent e-mailed me to share a conversation he had with his granddaughter. She came to him crying, and when he asked why, she said it was because Donald Trump had been elected president and she was afraid that her grandfather would be deported, as he is an immigrant.

I have heard similar stories over and over again from many people over the last week, and I have seen nothing like it in my lifetime. This is not the normal mourning that takes place when one party or another loses an election, it is an existential fear inspired by the campaign Donald Trump and his surrogates waged.

In her column for Maryland Reporter on Tuesday, Delegate Trent Kittleman tells Marylanders not to worry about a Trump presidency. She calls his inflammatory and reprehensible statements on the campaign trail “hyperbole.” She states that he is doing “everything possible to bring people together.”

I am frankly shocked at how thoroughly Delegate Kittleman misunderstands the fear that has gripped many Marylanders since the election. And I am aghast at her temerity in arguing based on absolutely zero evidence that Trump will be somehow a moderate and reasonable president.

Was Trump lying?

          The crux of Kittleman’s argument is that Trump lied to voters while on the campaign trail, that he didn’t really mean what he said. Let’s review for a second some of those statements and actions, in no particular order because it is difficult to weigh their relative odiousness.

  • He said that he thinks all Muslims should have to register with the government, building a totalitarian registry of citizens based on their religion.
  • He argued that there should be a religious test for all new immigrants to the United States, banning all Muslims from entering.
  • Trump stated that a judge of Mexican ancestry could not provide a neutral venue for the hearing of a court case simply because of his ancestry.
  • He called Mexican immigrants rapists.
  • He mocked a disabled reporter.
  • He said veterans like Senator John McCain who are captured in battle are not war heroes.
  • He proposed the immediate expulsion of millions of immigrants, which would require a massive ramping up of federal law enforcement and the disruption and destruction of entire communities.
  • For years, he claimed that President Obama was not born an American.
  • He mocked and demeaned women, and claimed that the 15 women who have accused him of sexual assault were all lying.

The list goes on, and on, and on.

If Donald Trump did not believe these statements when he made them, if he indeed does not plan to follow through with his proposals, then he lied more often and more audaciously than any other American politician I know of.

No evidence he was lying or exaggerating

But the evidence so far flies in the face of Kittleman’s assertion that his statements were hyperbolic.

Case in point: Among his first actions in office, Donald Trump appointed Steve Bannon as chief White House strategist and senior counselor. Bannon’s appointment was immediately praised by the Ku Klux Klan and the American Nazi Party. That’s not hyperbole, it’s fact.

Bannon presided over the conversion of Breitbart News into a mouthpiece for the white nationalist alt-right. They created a section on their website highlighting “Black Crime” and called Bill Kristol a “renegade Jew.” In an email to Republican leaders Bannon encouraged them to, ‘Let the grassroots turn on the hate’. Bannon’s appointment is entirely in keeping with Trump’s rhetoric on the campaign trail.

Nobody should be surprised at the fear many of us have heard from friends and family since Election Day. And the normalization of racism that we’ve seen as a result of the campaign should concern any public official.

Rise in hate crimes should be condemned

Across our state and the country, we’ve seen a steep rise in hate crimes. As many hate incidents have been reported to the Southern Poverty Law Center in the last week as are normally reported over a six month period. In Silver Spring, two churches were vandalized, one with the words “Trump nation – whites only.”

A school bus driver in Frederick County reportedly told a student that Trump would “send all of you back.” Schools across the state have reported racist graffiti, including at a school in Kittleman’s own county. In other states, assaults have been reported against Muslim and black Americans. Thank God that hasn’t happened in Maryland yet.

The statements Trump made on the campaign trail, the appointment of Bannon, and the vandalism and assaults committed by a subset of Trump supporters directly contradict basic American and Maryland values. And yet I have heard nothing from Republican leaders in Maryland regarding the recent incidents and Bannon’s appointment.

Quite the contrary. Gov. Hogan stated to the press that Trump’s election “could be good for the state.” If Kittleman, Hogan, and other Maryland Republicans want to help calm some of the fears about a Trump presidency, then they should be clearly condemning these hate crimes, and they should follow the lead of some national Republican figures who have made clear that Bannon has no place working in the White House.

They should exert pressure on the nominee of their party to fully and completely dissociate himself from hate groups and offer more than a half-hearted “stop it” to those who would commit hateful acts in his name, as Trump did on 60 Minutes.

Maryland voters will not just, as Delegate Kittleman states, hold her to her statements. They will hold accountable those who saw an outbreak of hate in our society and did nothing to prevent it.

Democratic Delegate Eric Luedtke of Montgomery County  represents District 14 in the House of Delegates.

  • SuziK

    Donald’s hyperbole echos that of another politician, Adolf Hitler. As early as 1922, there were apologists like Kittleman published in the news saying, in essence, Hitler didn’t really mean all those awful things he said. There is much to fear from a person who espouses the same rhetoric. Donald has been duly elected, but he will be watched, he will be judged, and people will express their concerns in regard to his presidency, as is their right.

  • Dale McNamee

    All of the rhetoric and antics of those protesters shows their poisonous indoctrination and educational ignorance and gives credibility to Trump’s statements and possible actions…

    So, maybe the protesters should grow up and stop whining and, along with their supposed professors, start learning American History, and Western Civilization…

    This is the rotted, poisonous fruit of of 100 years of Progressivism…

    Yes, I said it !

  • Johnny

    Although I generally agree with the points made in Delegate Luedtke’s article, let’s try and keep things in perspective. There have only been 11 hate crime “incidents” in Maryland since last Tuesday, most of which were at schools. AG Frosh seems to be dealing with the uptick appropriately by establishing a hate crime hotline, and I’m sure Gov Hogan is in the loop. Would a statement from Hogan condemning these incidents be appropriate? Sure. But he has a state to run, and I don’t think he needs to call a press conference every time a middle-schooler writes something stupid in a bathroom stall. Getting people overly spun up about these incidents is not constructive.

    I also don’t expect Hogan, state Republicans, or any state politicians to waste time criticizing Bannon or any of these other picks by Trump. What good does that do? Isn’t there enough endless banter from every news channel, website, and newspaper right now? Our leaders have a state to run, and it does no good to contribute to the endless commentary on the Trumpster fire that is going on with the presidential transition.

    To put Delegate Luedtke’s out-of-context quote back into context, Hogan thinks Trumps election “could be good for the state” in terms of the FBI relocating here. Hogan is pragmatic. He bravely broke from his party after criticizing nominees from both sides, but now he has to work with the winner to advance the interests of our state. Maybe leaders like Delegate Luedtke aren’t interested in the thousands of jobs the FBI move would bring, and would rather Hogan criticize Trump than work with him. I’m glad Hogan knows better, as he continues to demonstrate he is above partisan politics, unlike some of the delegates on both sides of our General Assembly.

  • Small Town Reporter

    One of characteristics of full blown Narcissistic Personality Disorder is deep seeded insecurity, which is often masked by overcompensating with bravado and creating a world where the NPD sufferer is the adored center of it. Other traits include a complete lack of empathy and the desire to hurt and control others. Maligning folks is where NPD sufferers derive a sense of self worth and superiority. Folks with NPD are also often paranoid and think the world is out to get them. The insecurity is programmed during childhood or early adulthood and arises out of rejection or fear of it. My mother (RIP) likened Trump to “Trash with Cash,” she said. “That’s what the old money thinks of him. No matter how many wives he collects or how much gold plated crap litters his plane, he knows the old guard thinks he’s white trash.” People with NPD are also masters at deception and manipulation, they are takers not givers and they will lead you down a path of destruction and then blame everyone but themselves when things blow up. We’re in for a loony ride with Trump, I just hope he continues to be his own worst enemy in a way that renders him ineffective until the adults get another chance in 2018 and 2020.