Senators debate empowering themselves to approve state schools superintendent

Senators debate empowering themselves to approve state schools superintendent

Sen. Jim Brochin left debates with Sen. Paul Pinsky on schools superintendent bill.

By Leo Traub

Capital News Service

Sen. Jim Brochin left debates with Sen. Paul Pinsky on schools superintendent bill.

Sen. Jim Brochin, left, debates with Sen. Paul Pinsky, right, on schools superintendent bill.

The Maryland Senate debated Thursday over an emergency bill that would give them greater influence over the Board of Education’s next superintendent appointee.

The bill, which Republican senators characterized as politically motivated, would require the Democrat-controlled Senate to authorize the Maryland Board of Education’s appointee for state superintendent.

The board of education is appointed by Gov. Larry Hogan, a Republican, and there is a pending vacancy in the seat for state superintendent. Some Republican senators expressed concern that the bill could be politically motivated.


Sen. Justin Ready, R-Carroll, said the timing of the bill is “suspicious.”

Since former Superintendent Lillian Lowery resigned in September to work for an education nonprofit, the position has been held in the interim by her then-deputy Jack Smith, who will become superintendent of Montgomery County public schools this summer.

Education spending has been a point of contention between Hogan and Democrats in the legislature.

Appointments by governors and discord among board of education members in states around the country have led to short tenures for superintendents, said the bill’s sponsor, Sen. Paul Pinsky, D-Prince George’s. Sometimes, superintendents only stay a few years before they are let go, he said, and having legislative involvement could help extend their terms.

Legislatures in 14 other states, including Virginia and Delaware, already have similar powers of approval over superintendent appointees, Pinsky said.

Lengthens a difficult search

Giving the Senate the ability to turn away superintendents politicizes the position and could lengthen an already difficult search, said Senate Minority Leader J. B. Jennings, Baltimore and Harford counties.

“You’re going to have special interest groups calling their legislators about this,” said Jennings.

The process for choosing superintendents is rigorous enough, with expert interviews and assessments that narrow down the best choice from a pool of 35 to 40 candidates, and it does not need more political involvement, said Sen. James Brochin, D-Baltimore.

The State school board typically appoints superintendents in June, but giving the Senate the power of approval could put potential candidates in a limbo until the General Assembly’s spring session, Jennings said.

The bill is scheduled for a preliminary vote Friday. Republicans consider it part of a package of legislation designed to put controls on the power of the governor.

About The Author

Capital News Service

Capital News Service is a student-powered news organization run by the University of Maryland Philip Merrill College of Journalism. For 26 years, we have provided deeply reported, award-winning coverage of issues of import to Marylanders. With bureaus in College Park, Annapolis and Washington run by professional journalists with decades of experience, we deliver news in multiple formats via partner news organizations, a destination Web site, a nightly on-air television newscast and affiliated social media channels (including Twitter and Facebook). We provide breaking news coverage, in-depth investigative and enterprise journalism, and serve as a laboratory for students to test and develop innovative new methods of reporting and telling stories. By providing a true newsroom experience to our students, we send them into the job market with real-world skills and the ability to shape the future of journalism. Only Merrill’s most motivated students are accepted into the Capital News Service program, and they go on to land internships and jobs at the nation’s finest news organizations: The New York Times, the Washington Post, CNN, the Associated Press, Politico, the Chicago Tribune, the Los Angeles Times, ProPublica, National Geographic, NBC News, The Dallas Morning News, the Washington City Paper, Washingtonian magazine, Money magazine, the Wall Street Journal and more.

Support Our Work!

We depend on your support. A generous gift in any amount helps us continue to bring you this service. Podcast


Do you support mandating Covid-19 vaccine for all municipal workers?

Subscribe to Our Newsletter