Sponsor of immigrant tuition bill says repeal efforts could cost millions

Sponsor of immigrant tuition bill says repeal efforts could cost millions

Sen. Jim Brochin

By Glynis Kazanjian

For MarylandReporter.com

Sen. Victor Ramirez

Sen. Victor Ramirez

The lead sponsor who objects to efforts to overturn his bill granting in-state college tuition to illegal immigrants said referendum efforts by opponents could cost the state millions and the drive is being funded by outside Tea Party interests.

“It costs the state a lot of money, and these guys are supposed to be fiscally conservative?”  Sen. Victor Ramirez, D-Prince Georges, said last Friday. “We’re going to spend millions of dollars potentially for a referendum.  It’s going to be more expensive to run the referendum than it is to fund the policy.”

“It’s definitely being driven by the Tea Party, not locally, but nationally,” Ramirez said.  “It’s people from the outside trying to tell Maryland what policy they should pass.”

Officials say cost is minimal

But state officials say the cost of putting the issue on the ballot is fairly minimal, and some organizers say there is little evidence of out-of-state funding for the petition drive.

“The petition verification process can be done with existing staff,” said Mary Wagner, state board voter registration director. “The state board of elections does not hire temporary employees to process, and it is my belief, neither do the local boards.”

Petitioners only have another four weeks to collect the first one-third of the 55,736 signatures that must be collected by June 30. The large numbers and short length of time help explain why only two laws have made it to a state-wide referendum in Maryland in the last 23 years, according to the elections board. Those were attempts to repeal measures banning Saturday night special handguns in 1988 and a permissive abortions bill in 1992. Both referendums failed.

The only costs associated with the referendum process would be mailing the petitions to local election boards for signature verification and printing a bill summary to be included with a sample ballot that is mailed out prior to each election, according to local and state election board officials.  The 2012 ballot will already include one constitutional amendment requiring judges of the orphans court to be lawyers in two counties.

Ramirez said he thought legal challenges would also contribute to referendum costs, but Assistant Attorney General Jeff Darsie said it was more a matter of potential time spent on litigation, not money.

“If you’re asking if we would hire additional counsel or outside lawyers, the answer is no,” Darsie said. “It would cost [time] to the extent that we’re working on litigation and we’re not working on other things.  I don’t know that there will be any litigation on this at all.”

Outside funding is denied

Various groups have been actively involved with signature gathering since referendum efforts began last month, but two major players denied any knowledge of outside Tea Party involvement.

“It has been a trend with Democrats across the nation to accuse Tea Partiers of being some-form of ‘astro-turf,’ ” (as opposed to grassroots), said  Maryland Society of Patriots Founder Sam Hale. “These comments, especially in regards to Maryland, show a basic ignorance of what the Tea Party is.  Opposite of MoveOn.org and most Democrat campaigns, off-shore funding and the need to pay activists an hourly rate is not the Tea Party’s style.”
“Victor Ramirez is not one to be commenting on out of state donations as he received extensive support from CASA de Maryland, who has received donations from throughout the world, including Hugo Chavez,” Hale added.

Sen. Jim Brochin

Sen. Jim Brochin

Brochin: No signs of Tea Party

Sen. Jim Brochin, (D-Baltimore County), a prominent Democrat who supports the referendum, said a successful effort to overturn the legislation would mean a majority of voters don’t like the law and the process is part of checks and balances and a system of democracy.

“I haven’t heard anything about the Tea Party,” Brochin said. “I represent a pretty conservative district, and I am a Democrat, but I can tell you that in the liberal parts of my district, I have liberal Democrats coming up to me on a consistent basis saying, ‘What about illegal don’t these people understand?’ This isn’t a Tea Party issue.”

When asked if citizens should have the right to bring issues to referendum, Ramirez said, “Of course, but then why have a legislature?  Where does it stop?  I thought we were elected by the people and were accountable to the people.  At the end of the day, if people don’t like the decisions and the votes we’re taking, that’s what elections are for.”

Burns supports referendum

But Del. Emmett Burns, Baltimore County Democrat who voted against the bill and supports the referendum, disagrees.

“I do think the people should decide whether or not they want this to happen,” Burns said. “This was pushed by a very liberal wing of the Democratic Party in the House and it was a very, very close vote.  I think due to the closeness of the vote, the constituents of the state should make that decision.”

The bill passed 74-65, getting just three more than the required constitutional majority of 71 needed for passage.

Signatures being collected

Over the weekend, Tea Party groups and other opponents of the legislation were out collecting signatures.  Brad Botwin of Help Save Maryland said his group collected 800 signatures at the Towsontown Festival and another affiliated group collected 200 signatures at the Chesapeake boat show. The Maryland Republican party is also likely to send out a mass e-mail this week containing petition information, GOP spokesman Ryan Mahoney said.

New guidelines for petition signatures are still awaiting final approval by the Office of the Attorney General that is expected sometime this week. Signature standards will have been relaxed slightly, said Donna Duncan, state board election management director.

Many petitions will be generated and printed from computers.  Petition forms that do not have the bill summary stapled to the signature page will not be validated, Duncan said.

About The Author

Len Lazarick


Len Lazarick was the founding editor and publisher of MarylandReporter.com and is currently the president of its nonprofit corporation and chairman of its board He was formerly the State House bureau chief of the daily Baltimore Examiner from its start in April 2006 to its demise in February 2009. He was a copy editor on the national desk of the Washington Post for eight years before that, and has spent decades covering Maryland politics and government.


  1. blake sutherland

     Well well now Mr. Ramirez when the voters reject this bill via referendum will you say that the many attempts by you and your bill sponsors over the past 4 years were a waste of time and MONEY. I will.

  2. Retired Chief Petty Officer

    If each person in this state who has ever sworn to defend and uphold the Constitution of the United states would sign this petition, the referendum would be ensured. I urge all Active and Retired military and their families to seek out and sign a petition today in order to honor your mothers. They understood the rules of immigration and lawful voting. Honor them by insisting that others do as well.

  3. Anonymous

    If Ramirez was even a little bit fiscally responsible and/or concerned with the people of Maryland he would have voted against the bill. Instead he wants to protect the rights of illegal alien criminals and doesn’t care that it will cost the state hundreds of millions of our tax dollars. Illegal aliens already cost this state almost $2 billion a year. The legislature, which includes Ramirez, continually raise our taxes because of their fiscal irresponsibility and total disregard for the law and he has the unmitigated gall to talk about “fiscal responsibility”.


    Hey Little. VIKTOR YOU LIEI!!! This is being done entirly BY VOLUNTEERS. You know PATRIOTS who Love their country. You need to take a class on. THE CONSTITUTION!! Did. You come m
    Here LEGALLy and are you a DUAL CITIZEN ? You came to reap Americas rewards and then try and turn our country into a third world Marxist Sewer!! Casa de MD needs to be INVESTIGATED and SHUTDOWN!!! http://Www.helpsavemaryland.com

  5. Against Illegal Tuition Breaks

    Sen. Ramirez is full of it and Sen. Brochin is right on target. The feeling against this bill is widespread and grassroots. This bill is going down.

  6. Cecil Calvert

    By the way, this is not costing the Tax Dollars Millions of dollars. This is another fabrication by Vicktor. I am part of the Petition Effort in Maryland and no tax dollars have used on this petition drive as of now. All press has been free, all media, free, going out and getting signatures, free, meeting new friends of bi partisan alikes. This is a Bi Partisan support driven Petition Drive, thank goodness this Paper prints the truth, unlike the Sun.

  7. Cecil Calvert

    Comrade Vicktor needs to get a grip, he obviously does not understand the constitution if he feels the legislature has the final word. Hey nimrod, if you lived here you whole life and learned the constitution, you would understand that, We The People have the right to petition your bills if we don’t like them, that is why we live in a Democracy fool.

  8. Anonymous

    Talk about double speak! Providing a subsidy for illegal immigrant college students isn’t a problem for Senator Ramierz but a statewide repeal referendum is a waste of money?

    When asked if citizens should have the right to bring issues to referendum, Ramirez said, “Of course, but then why have a legislature? Where does it stop? I thought we were elected by the people and were accountable to the people. At the end of the day, if people don’t like the decisions and the votes we’re taking, that’s what elections are for.”

    Yes Senator Ramierz you are accountable to ALL legal Maryland residents, those of us who support this state with our income, property & sales taxes, along with the ever growing number of “fees” better known as taxes. Instead of biting the bullet & trying to fix budgetary problems, you & your Democratic colleagues are proud to play games, picking winners & losers in hopes of future votes. Those MD taxpayers who do not tote the progressive Democratic line or the Republican line are out in the cold when it comes to having our voices heard. I am sure that whatever opposition that currently exists will be redistricted out of existence come this fall. Maryland will then be truly Blue…and nearly broke!

  9. Graham B. Henry Jr.

    It seems that Sen. Victor Ramirez does not get it. The freedom to try to get a petition to referendum no matter the cost is the good ole American way.
    what? is he a alien?


  1. The Dysfunction of Maryland Politics and The National Scene » Sponsor of immigrant tuition bill says repeal efforts could cost millions – Emmit Burns and James Brochin Support Petition Drive - [...] temporary employees to process, and it is my belief, neither do the local boards.” Read more: http://marylandreporter.com/2011/05/04/immigrant-tuition-repeal-efforts-could-costmillions/#ixzz1Mij... Under Creative…
  2. BlueRidgeForum » In-State-Tuition Referendum: Is Support Widening? - [...] a very useful but strangely titled article (because it is largely about the reach of support for the referendum…
  3. The Dysfunction of Maryland Politics and The National Scene » Petition Drive in Maryland Garners Bi Partisan Support – Democrats are speaking up against giving in-state tuition to illegal alien students in Maryland - [...] in the second news story I’ve seen today on THE petition, I see that the Maryland Reporter story by…
  4. Two informative news stories today on THE petition drive… « Potomac Tea Party Report - [...] in the second news story I’ve seen today on THE petition, I see that the Maryland Reporter story by…

Support Our Work!

We depend on your support. A generous gift in any amount helps us continue to bring you this service.