When you work in a consulting role, there’s an urge to dive into solutions the moment you’re presented with a problem. After all, that’s what you’re there for, right? Clients come to you with challenges, and your job is to fix them.
But here’s something every consultant learns quickly, often the hard way:
You can’t solve a problem until you’re sure what the actual problem is.
Most of the value we bring as consultants isn’t in having the flashiest solutions – it’s in helping clients see clearly what they’re dealing with. And that starts with identifying the problem properly.
Why It’s So Easy to Solve the Wrong Thing
Let’s say a client tells you: “Sales are down – we need a new marketing strategy.”
Sounds like a direction, right? But is that the real issue?
Maybe sales are down because pricing hasn’t kept pace with competitors. Or because service quality is slipping. Or maybe it’s a mix of internal bottlenecks and market changes. If you jump into marketing tactics without stepping back, you could spend weeks building a solution to a symptom, not a cause.
That’s the classic trap. And it’s exactly why problem definition is the most important (and underrated) part of the consulting process. Rushing in with a solution before verifying the real problem is like building a house on the wrong foundation – it might look fine at first, but it won’t hold up.
The Difference Between a Symptom and a Problem
One of the first real consulting skills to develop is the ability to disentangle symptoms from root issues.
Clients will often describe what they see: low revenue, high churn, missed targets. These are indicators – valuable ones – but they’re rarely the problem itself. Our job is to dig deeper and ask:
- What’s causing the decline?
- When did it start?
- Where is it concentrated?
- Who is impacted, and how?
The goal is to get past surface-level complaints and identify the structural issues underneath. Think of it like being a business doctor – you’re not just treating pain, you’re diagnosing what’s causing it. And just like in medicine, a wrong diagnosis in business can lead to the wrong treatment, wasting time and resources.
Now, let’s take a look at some things you should consider adding to your problem-solving strategy.
1. Clarify the Objective Before Anything Else
It sounds simple, but it’s often overlooked: before you start analysing anything, make sure you understand what the client is trying to achieve.
You’d be surprised how often teams rush into problem-solving mode without a clear sense of what success looks like. Is it more revenue? Improved customer satisfaction? Faster time to market?
Ask questions like:
- What would a win look like for you in three months?
- What are we trying to change – and for whom?
- Are there constraints we need to work within?
When you know what matters most to the client, you’re better equipped to define a meaningful, focused problem. Without that clarity, even a technically brilliant solution can miss the mark entirely.
2. Break Big Problems into Smaller, Testable Questions
Once you’ve got a handle on the general issue, the next step is making it manageable.
Big, fuzzy problems like “Improve operations” or “Fix our growth strategy” don’t help anyone, not even the smartest team in the room. They’re too broad to act on.
Try breaking the challenge down into a series of questions:
- Is our growth issue about customer acquisition, retention, or both?
- Is one product line dragging performance, or is it across the board?
- Are internal inefficiencies costing us more than market changes?
This not only sharpens the team’s focus – it helps you structure your analysis around testable hypotheses, which makes your work far more grounded and actionable. It also helps break analysis paralysis, giving your team a concrete place to begin exploring.
3. Pressure-Test the Problem Statement
After you’ve defined a working problem statement, it’s tempting to move straight into analysis. But here’s a trick worth building into your process: pause, and test it.
Ask yourself (and your team):
- Does this problem explain what’s happening?
- Have we validated it with data, or are we still running on assumptions?
- Is this the most urgent thing to solve right now?
Sometimes, the process of refining the problem helps uncover blind spots in your initial thinking. And that’s a good thing; it’s much cheaper to rethink early than to pivot late in the project. It also ensures you’re aligned with the client on what you’re solving, before time and trust are spent.
4. Reframe When Needed – Clients Appreciate It
One of the biggest misconceptions is that clients always know what they want. The truth? They often think they do, until the data – and your questions – tell a different story.
Being willing to reframe the problem isn’t about being difficult. It’s about adding value. When you help a client realise they’ve been focused on the wrong lever – or that they’ve misunderstood the true cost of an issue – you elevate the conversation. You’re not just a problem-solver anymore. You’re a trusted advisor.
Pro tip: Do this respectfully, and bring evidence. Instead of saying “You’re wrong,” try, “Here’s what we’re seeing based on the data – and it might suggest a slightly different challenge than what we originally thought.”
Clients don’t expect perfection, but they do value clarity, and they’ll remember who helped them get there.
5. Define Success Up Front
A well-defined problem is incomplete without a clear understanding of how success will be measured.
Before your team gets deep into Excel or PowerPoint, align with your client on what the finish line looks like. Is it a percentage improvement? A set of recommendations? An operational playbook they can implement?
This helps manage expectations and ensures your final deliverable solves the right problem, not just the one you started with. Plus, it gives your team a compass to refer back to when choices start to multiply mid-project.
Start With the Right Question
As a consultant, your value isn’t just in building frameworks or crunching numbers. It’s in asking better questions – ones that help clients see their challenges more clearly.
When you start with the wrong problem, you risk spending time, money, and energy fixing something that was never broken. But when you take the time to define the real issue, based on context, data, and thoughtful inquiry, you unlock the potential for real impact.
So before you sharpen your slide deck or fire up Excel, pause and ask:
Are we solving the right problem?
That moment of clarity? That’s where good consulting begins.
Recent Comments