Photo below: As the speech began, Senate President Mike Miller, left, Gov. Larry Hogan and House Speaker Michael Busch were all smiles. Photo above: As the speech went on, the smiles turned to frowns. (Photos by Rebecca Lessner, MarylandReporter.com)
By Len Lazarick
Right after Gov. Larry Hogan finished his State of the State speech Wednesday, one Republican lawmaker quipped that the Democrats were heading to the nurse’s station. They wanted to have their hands looked at after sitting on them for an hour.
That was a gross exaggeration. The speech was only a half hour long, and some Democratic legislators did give up a smattering of applause here and there.
Mostly they sat in stony silence as their Republican colleagues jumped to their feet repeatedly, clapping and even cheering as Hogan recycled much of his campaign rhetoric, then detailed a legislative program to implement some of his promises.
Senate President Mike Miller, smiling at the outset, was scowling by the end of the speech.
Afterward, Miller called it “horrible” and said the governor was trashing Maryland and offering up campaign promises he couldn’t fulfill.
House Speaker Michael Busch was more restrained, but equally critical, saying “you campaign with slogans, but you govern with facts.”
Sen. Guy Guzzone of Howard County called it “the worst speech ever;” Baltimore County Executive Kevin Kamenetz called it “a very partisan” speech.
Tired of the stump speech
Democrats have grown tired of Hogan’s repetition of his standard stump speech that he continues to use with variations depending on the setting. He used parts of it in his inaugural address two weeks ago, then lifted them again last week speaking to a Tech Council dinner.
The new governor dishes out what is red meat for his supporters, but totally inedible to these Democratic vegetarians. They’re tired of the slogans that blame them implicitly for what is wrong with the state, including high taxes, over-spending, over-regulation, businesses closing, people wanting to leave.
The Maryland Democratic Party provided a fact-checking press release. It offered partisan spin but also useful comparative facts. The party even used the conservative Tax Foundation to show Maryland’s business climate and taxes are not as bad as Hogan says.
House Majority Leader Anne Kaiser gave a video response to Hogan’s speech, taped before she knew its content. She painted a mirror image of a state in a parallel universe of good schools, educated work force and high-tech job growth.
If you strip out the campaign rhetoric, Hogan for the first time lays out some specific legislative proposals. Most are designed to fulfill campaign promises, especially rolling back taxes.
Rain tax: As he repeatedly promised, Hogan will ask for repeal of the stormwater remediation fee the state mandated to meet federal pollution requirements. Busch and other leaders say the nine counties and the city already have enough flexibility to change it as they will and no repeal is necessary.
Retirement income: As promised in a fall forum, Hogan said, “Eventually, once we solve our current budget crisis, and turn our economy around, I want to reach the point where we are able to do away with income taxes on all retirement income, just as many other states have done.”
The price tag on that is very high. Instead, Hogan will submit more modest legislation that repeals income taxes on pensions for retired military, police, fire and first responders. In a follow-up press release, the governor’s office explained that this will be implemented over several years.
Personal Property Tax: The state no longer collects a tax on property, such as equipment and inventory, owned by businesses, but the counties do. Hogan would eliminate the tax on property totaling less than $10,000 largely affecting small businesses. This costs the state nothing, but eliminates the major paperwork entailed. In return, the counties will get back more highway user revenues.
Gas tax: In perhaps the biggest tax bombshell, Hogan would eliminate the automatic increases in the gas tax passed in 2013. This will reduce the amount coming in to the Transportation Trust Fund.
Democrats fear this cut in revenues will spell the death of the Purple and Red light rail lines.
Hogan’s budget and these tax cuts are major legislative goals that will be tough to achieve. But he also chose to tackle two election law reforms that were not part of his core agenda.
Campaign Finance: Hogan won his election with $2.5 million in public financing, but that largely depleted a fund built up over many years. He wants to restore the voluntary check-off on Maryland income tax forms and replenish the fund.
At a hearing before the Senate Budget and Taxation Committee just a few hours after Hogan’s speech, Democratic Sen. Jim Brochin of Baltimore County testified on his two bills that would do exactly what Hogan is proposing on the gas tax and Fair Campaign Financing Fund. He noted that Hogan “stole” his ideas, but now he has the administration behind those ideas as well.
Redistricting: In a move applauded by Common Cause and the League of Women Voters, Hogan will also create a commission to study Maryland’s redistricting process with the goal of creating an independent, bipartisan commission to replace the highly partisan political process that created some of the most gerrymandered and contorted congressional districts in the nation.
Miller and Busch both played key roles in the current redistricting process, and Hogan would like to take that power away. But not this year.
He already has enough battles to fight with these two presiding officers.
WBAL radio’s Rob Lang has extended audio reactions of Busch and Miller to Hogan’s speech, along with Senate Minority Leader J.B. Jennings.
WBAL TV posts the full half-hour video of the speech and the full text.
I loved “Mike” Miller’s whining about the possible repeal of the “automatic” gas tax that’s attached to the CPI… “We need the tax to support the infrastructure” he said.
I wonder if he felt that way when he & his fellow Democrats raided the Transportation Fund to “balance the budget”… Infrastructure eh ?
He disgusts me as do the Democrats…
Maryland Democrats will have to produce more than a “fact checker” to change the perception of many voters since after each & every tax, toll & fee hike, we were assured that the increased revenues would “solve” all our budget issues. Maybe these legislators assume that every MD voter has been in a Rip Van Winkle trance during the past 8 years, but rest assured we haven’t. The last election, especially with Gov Hogan winning, one would think that they had gotten the message. Seems from the sour puss faces they didn’t get the message sent loud & clear.
Amen to an independent redistricting process! Gerrymandering by either party is a slap in the face to every resident of the state, ensuring some are more equal than others.
Thanks for what seems objective reporting. Much appreciated Len Lazarick. That is more needed than all the inflated retoric.
The State needs common sense.
I watched Catherine Pugh nearly in tears exclaiming how Governor Hogan “crushed the dreams of the Red & Purple Lines for people” on the news…
DREAMS ? We’ve had nothing but dreams for the last 8 years that have nearly destroyed this state,Del. Pugh !
Get your rich donors, as well as those who would profit from these schemes, and the “dreaming supporters”, as well as yourself and any other Democratic legislators, to pony up the money,NOT THE TAXPAYERS !
Try setting up a “Go Fund ME” page… Let’s see how popular they are …
Had to love her comment about not building the Red & Purple lines would harm the people. Maybe if a majority of MD residents understood that building the lines is just a drop in the bucket when it comes to mass transit lines. In addition to saddling ALL state taxpayers with building costs, we will also be on the hook for subsidizing those who use mass transit since ticket revenues never cover operating costs. I’m sure all those living in Garrett County or the Eastern Shore are eager to pony up even more $$ to alleviate transportation problems around the DC suburbs & Baltimore.
I agree !
You mentioned Garrett County & the Eastern Shore… I seem to recall the “horror” of the DC-Baltimore types that Governor Hogan ACTUALLY visited Western Md. & the Eastern Shore and pledged to do his best to help the farmers and other “ignored” people much to the “elites” chagrin… Montgomery County,Prince Georges County & Baltimore City will have to join the “rest of us”…
Regarding “mass transit”… Randall O’Toole’s blog at Cato@liberty analyzes the “Return on Infrastructure” : http://www.cato.org/blog/getting-returns-infrastructure?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Cato-at-liberty+%28Cato+at+Liberty%29
When I was growing up in Pittsburgh, many of the surrounding boroughs had their own bus companies, and a private company ran the street cars in the city and boroughs where the tracks ran… Then, the Port Authority was created and all of the bus/streetcar companies went out of business and service decayed and fares shot up !
Let those who want mass transit PAY FULL PRICE for it… NO SUBSIDIES ! Let the gas tax be for the roads that those who pay the tax use. Mass transit doesn’t pay any taxes on fuel ! So,no more tax susidies !
Unfortunately “my” LD20 legislators (we only get Dems since we are gerrymandered into compliance) did not sit on their hands. Newly elected Del Will Smith frowned throughout the speech (I have NEVER seen him frown, usually smiling, glad-handing people in LD20) and holding his hands up in a sort of “here is the church, this is the steeple” configuration. Too obvious to miss. And they say they want to work with the new administration; this “show” made it clear they have no intention of working with, but instead expecting kowtowing. This group have already sent out invitations to constituents to show up Monday Feb 9th from 6-8pm Lowe HOB for District 20 Night! They are going to treat this new Administration much as they do us, their constituents: shut up and do as you are told, vote for us, we know what’s best. Geesh.
Maybe it’s time for the constituents to give the legislators “what for” at District 20 Night…
Make them feel very uncomfortable… Challenge them at every turn… Make their jobs “widow makers”…