We’re 12 days away from the deadline for campaign finance reports for the first four months of 2018. But Capital News Service did an analysis of where the Democratic candidates had been raising money during 2017.
By Chris Cioffi
Capital News Service
A crowded field of Democrats are elbowing for position before June’s primary, pulling in millions of dollars in hopes of being the party’s nominee to take on Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan.
Some candidates are forming networks of small donors, while others are focusing more on checks from large contributors — including celebrities like Dave Chappelle, Domonique Foxworth and Ashley Judd. Capital News Service analyzed the candidates’ campaign finance report data for 2017. Here’s what we found.
1. Ben Jealous took a page from Bernie Sanders’ playbook by raising lots of money from small contributions.
Former NAACP head and longtime Maryland activist Ben Jealous is a strong advocate for progressive policies like universal healthcare and a $15 minimum wage.
He stumped for Bernie Sanders in 2016, and received his endorsement last year.
Sanders’ campaign raised large sums from small donors, and Jealous has too. Over 9,600 people contributed to the Jealous campaign, the majority giving $250 or less. Those small donations make up about 16% of his total contributions — the most raised from small donors by a Democrat.
Building a small donor network gives candidates a funder base that can be called on to meet funding goals, said Jerusalem Demsas, Jealous’ deputy communications director.
“It’s not about the amount of money coming from Maryland. It’s about the number of Marylanders,” she said. “They’re able to give multiple times.”
State Sen. Rich Madaleno, D-Montgomery, and Krish Vignarajah, who served in multiple roles in the Obama administration, also received significant funds from small contributions.
2. Several candidates got most of their money from people who gave more than $2,500 — but Jim Shea got by far the most.
Jim Shea, who previously chaired the Baltimore-based law firm of Venable LLP, loaned his campaign a half-million dollars — and still raised more money than any other candidate, mostly from large donors. He got about 60% of his contributions from donors giving over $2,500. The Shea camp’s average donation was $1,020 — one of the highest in the race.
Getting large contributions from fewer contributors won’t mean fewer votes, Kathryn Gilley, Shea’s communications director said in an email.
“Our base of support comes from meeting voters across the state and talking to them where they live about the issues that matter to them most,” she said.
A balanced number of small and large contributors can be beneficial in candidate fundraising efforts, said Todd Eberly, a political science professor at St. Mary’s College of Maryland.
If you get support from a contributor who gives the maximum allowed by law, they can’t contribute again later, he said. Maryland law prohibits a person from contributing directly or indirectly more than $6,000 to a political committee during an election cycle.
“What you want is this army of folks who can’t come close to the max, but they can give you 20 dollars or 50 dollars, and you can go back to them in a few weeks,” he said.
Jealous and Baltimore County Executive Kevin Kamenetz each got about half of their money from donations of over $2,500.
Ross got 60% of his contributions from larger donors. That’s helping get the message to voters, said Daniel Ensign, a spokesman for the Ross campaign.
“There’s obviously a big difference between who we’re talking to and who we’re raising money from,” he said.
3. The people at Jim Shea’s job really like him.
Shea is a longtime attorney who worked as managing partner and chairman of Baltimore-based Venable LLP, that he helped build into one of the largest law firms in the country.
The campaign received about 30% of its total contributions from donors listing Venable as their employer. Gilley, Shea’s communications director, said it makes sense that those who know him support him.
“As governor, Jim will never be beholden to anyone but the people of the state of Maryland and his own conscience,” she said.
4. Famous people in Hollywood and the Big Apple want a piece of Maryland’s election.
Jealous got funds from Troy Carter, a Spotify executive and the former manager of Meghan Trainor and Lady Gaga.
Jealous also got financial help from Jada Smith and max contributions from his godbrother — entertainer Dave Chappelle — and Chappelle’s wife. He also got the max from philanthropist George Soros and Ben Cohen, co-founder of Ben and Jerry’s.
Alec Ross, a former advisor to Hillary Clinton at the State Department, got $1,000 from Domonique Foxworth, a former NFL and University of Maryland cornerback. He also got maximum checks from 21st Century Fox CEO James Murdoch, and his wife Kathryn Murdoch.
Vignarajah got $6,000 from fund manager and Clinton fundraiser James Harmon and his wife Jane Harmon. She also got $1,500 from Washington Redskins tight end Vernon Davis. Ashley Judd also gave Vignarajah $2,000 and worked with her on parts of her platform.
Celebrity chef Mario Batali, accused of harassing women in December, contributed $6,000 to her campaign in October. Elizabeth Waickman, Vignarajah campaign’s communications director, said the campaign spent Batali’s contribution to hold a sexual harassment forum at Johns Hopkins University.
5. People living in California and New York have deep pockets for Maryland Democrats.
Non-celebrities in the two large states have been big donors for several candidates in this year’s race.
That makes sense, because “New York and California are the banks for national Democratic campaigns,” Eberly said.
The support is good, but it’s not always beneficial, he said. “These large groups or outside donors, they can give you money, but they can’t give you a vote.”
Nearly half of Jealous’ money came from contributors with a California address and 13% came from New York. Jealous was born and spent his early years in California.
Demsas, Jealous’ deputy communications director, said the candidate’s national appeal is crucial for mounting a bid against Hogan, who also has a national profile. She also pointed out that though Maryland donors gave less, more were based in the state than elsewhere.
Like Jealous, Ross got more than half of his campaign funds from California and New York.
Ross spokesman Daniel Ensign said many of the donors outside the state know Ross from his time at the nonprofit One Economy. It assisted NGOs (non-government organizations) starting online communities and integrated technology into diplomacy.
Vignarajah received a total of 34% of her contributions from donors in California and New York.
6. Kevin Kamenetz, Rushern Baker and Rich Madaleno each have drawn a lot of money from their home areas.
Prince George’s County Executive Rushern Baker received 14% of his funds from people living in Prince George’s County areas like Bowie, Upper Marlboro and Hyattsville. He received about 20% of his funds from contributors that listed a D.C. address. Roughly 65% listed a Maryland address.
A big challenge for political newcomers running for statewide office is getting their name and message out beyond their home areas, Eberly said.
He cited a Mason-Dixon poll released in March as a measure of candidate name recognition. The poll found that Baker is backed by about a quarter of Democratic primary voters surveyed.
Kamenetz, Baltimore County’s executive, raised over 90% of his money from contributors within Maryland — and about 20% had a Baltimore address.
The Mason-Dixon poll found that Kamenetz was backed by about 15% of voters surveyed and Jealous was backed by 14 percent.
Kamenetz’s campaign, which has just over $2 million in the bank, did not respond to requests for comment.
The rest of the field got 13%, but 36% of voters said they still hadn’t made up their minds.
Madaleno raised about 41% from Montgomery County towns. He represents the county’s District 18 in the Maryland Senate.
7. Several candidates have made sizable contributions to their own campaigns
Shea has plowed a half-million dollars into his own campaign. Madaleno and Vignarajah loaned themselves $124,000 and $100,000 respectively.
Each of the candidates’ campaign loan made up about a quarter of their campaign total.
Shea’s contribution appeared to kickstart his push to raising over $1.5 million. But the other two each raised less than $350,000, and that could mean trouble.
“If you are relatively well off and you have the money to lend yourself, then there’s nothing wrong with that,” Eberly said. “If that ends up being one of your major sources of money, that tends to be a problem.”
Madaleno’s press secretary Marguerite Gallorini said the campaign was pleased with its start.
“While we didn’t lead the pack in fundraising last year, the campaign is extremely proud of our accomplishments,” she said.
Waickman, the Vignarajah campaign’s communications director, said the candidate loaned herself the money because female candidates have historically had a harder time raising money than their male counterparts.
“As a whole, women candidates are much less likely to self finance,” she said. “And women have the hardest time raising money in this era of big money politics.”
She said that the loan boosted the campaign in the early going, but does not indicate that the campaign was in trouble. As more people hear from Vignarajah, fundraising has accelerated.
“I say it’s a challenge,” she said. “But it’s not insurmountable.”
Two candidates, James Jones and Ralph Jaffe, did not file 2017 disclosures.
Capital News Service did not annualize the campaign finance reports of Republican Hogan and Lt. Gov. Boyd Rutherford, who run as a ticket but can fundraise separately.
The two candidates raised almost $5.5 million last year and had over $9 million cash on hand, more than all the Democrats combined. The incumbents also have no primary opponents.
As state elected officials, Hogan and Rutherford are not allowed to raise or solicit funds during the legislature’s 90-day session, a ban that also applied to Madaleno, but none of the other Democrats.